Gillman vs. Holmes County Schools
Gillman vs. Holmes County Schools Save Email Print
Posted: 9:03 PM May 12, 2008
Last Updated: 9:58 AM May 13, 2008
Reporter: Mark Vaughn


A | A | A

A local case, that's drawing national attention, got underway on Monday in the federal courthouse in downtown Panama City.

Ponce de Leon High School Student Heather Gillman is suing the Holmes County School Board for not letting her wear pro-gay rights clothing.

Gillman was the first to take the witness stand Monday morning, saying she was told not to wear anything that could be seen as sexual, including shirts she made with the slogan "Equal, Not Special Rights."

Gillman testified for more than an hour.

Ponce de Leon Principal David Davis also took the stand, but for a considerably longer period of time.

Davis apparently told a student not to tell anyone she was gay.

Some of her classmates decided to protest Davis' stance by writing "GP", for ‘Gay Pride’, on the faces and arms, and wearing pro gay rights shirts.

Lawyers questioned Davis for more than four hours about why he wouldn't allow students the students to proclaim their support for gay rights.

Davis testified the clothing was disruptive to the educational process.

Testimony and closing arguments should wrap-up on Tuesday.

Federal Judge Richard Smoak will decide the case, there is no jury.

There is no word as to when he'll render a verdict.

More Stories
Early Morning Panama City Beach Shooting

Tourism Officials Happy with Turnout Panama City Beach Fourth of July

Market Minute - Monday July 6th

Whale Shark Spotted Off Panama City Beach Coast

Triathlete death goes to court

Kottkamp’s Political Decision?

Extended Unemployment Benefits Flowing

Facebook Discussion Leads to Molestation Charges

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: a Location: pdlhs on May 19, 2008 at 10:15 AM
I think it is very wrong for this to contiinue going on like it is. It has caused a big problem for everyone!! Homosexuals have the freedom of speech but homophobes dont? that is wrong in every way!! Mr. Davis as well as the whole staff of PDL has put up with alot from this gay stuff!! Heather isnt even a homosexual but she wants to stand up for them and ruin her senior year because they might make us wear uniforms!! Its all stupid and its an abomination to GOD!! Read the Bible!!! All homosexuals will NOT enter the gates of Heaven!! GO GOD!!!! not heather!!!

Posted by: pdlhs parent Location: pdl on May 14, 2008 at 11:29 PM
these people don't have a clue as to what is going on. the case started because a child went to mr. davis with a complaint of being harassed. if he had taken care of the other kids & their bullying it would never have gone this far. if the kid wasn't gay & was being teased because she was overweight would he have told her to let it go & suggest losing weight? no i think not. i think to much religion is brought into the school system in holmes county. god is great & i am a firm believer but i also believe that people can use their authority to push their beliefs on to other people. i feel that this is what mr. davis enjoys. this isn't the only problem at this school. i think it starts with who you are & what you can get away with. pdl has some wonderful teachers & employees but i have seen & heard alot of things since i've been in this community & if things were investigated i don't know if pdlh would remain under the same officials. proud parent of kids with rights!!! go heather

Posted by: Michael Greene Location: Panama City Beach on May 13, 2008 at 10:07 PM
Holmes' County Parent: If you think this case was based on hearing their names on the 10 o'clock news or the fact they wanted special rights, I suggest you go back and read the article, as well as the constitution again! These students stood up for something that was given to them by the constitution, yet was taken away due to ignorance and a bibilical beliefs. Freedom of speech is the basis and a very key amendment that allows Americans to voice their views, as well as thoughts, through not only vebral communication but also non-verbal. As a former gay student that grew up and went to school in a similar setting (Wewahitchka), I stand up and applaud Heather and the other students for standing up for themselves, their beliefs and their rights! I would like to suggest to you, "Holmes County Parent" that you sit in on some of the same history and civic classes as these courageous student are taking! G.P Heather and supporting students!!!

Posted by: MIKE HARRELL Location: BAY COUNTY on May 13, 2008 at 06:16 PM
I WAS BORN AND RAISED IN SAME COMMUNITY AS DAVID DAVIS. DON'T PARTICULARLY LIKE THE MAN. BUT I HAVE TO GIVE HIM CREDIT, HE IS 10000 TIMES THE MAN AS RICHARD SMOCK. CAN NOT SEE HOW HE CAN UPHOLD THIS KIND OF PERVERSION IN SCHOOL SYSTEM.IT IS NO WONDER OUR SOCIETY AND NATION IS SO SCREWED UP WITH THE PERFECT FOOLS WE HAVE TELL US WHAT TO DO. THERE IS ONE THING I KNOW FOR A FACT IS THAT OLD RICHARD IS GOING TO BEND HIS OLD KNEE AND CONFESS THAT HE WAS WRONG BEFORE THE ULTIMATE JUDGE. THANK YOU

Posted by: student from PDL Location: PDL HS on May 13, 2008 at 05:15 PM
I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU BECAUSE I KNOW HOW MRS. JOHNSON IS AND SHE WOULD NOT PUT UP WITH ANY OF IT! I GO TO PDL AND IT HAS CAUSED ALOT OF CONTROVERSY HERE,MY FRIENDS AND I THINK THAT ITS STUPID AND WE ARE SICK AND TIRED OF HEARING ABOUT IT BECAUSE WE ARE STRAIGHT. WE KNOW THAT OUR PRINCIPLE IS A CHRISTIAN AND HE, LIKE US, DOES NOT LIKE THE FACT THAT THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON. WE HAVE HAD PEOPLE COME UP TO US AT SCHOOL TO ASK IF WE SUPPORT GAYS AND WE SAID NO. WE ARE AT SCHOOL TO LEARN AND THIS HAS CAUSED TROUBLE.

Posted by: Mary Location: Franklin County, FL on May 13, 2008 at 02:02 PM
After working in the Franklin County School System for more than 25 years, I've seen many changes in the clothing students wear. I feel that a student should come to school to get an education not to advertise whether they are gay or straight. In my opinion all students should have to wear uniforms. I applaud Mr. Davis.

Posted by: Sandra Location: Panama City on May 13, 2008 at 11:54 AM
I don't particulary agree with confederate flag shirts. (A symbol of hate and fear in my eyes) However I respect another persons right to wear it if they so choose. Students in this school are permitted to wear shirts with the confederate flag why can't students wear shirts in support of gays and lesbians? And why would a principal whose JOB it is to protect ALL students tell a student that is going to him for help (because she has been teased about being gay) just to not tell anyone she is gay?? I would think he would realize how quickly something like teasing a classmate about being gay could escalate into something so much worse. What would Mr. Davis had done had those same kids later on that day beaten that student because she was gay? I am proud of Heather Gillman and all of her classmates for standing up for the rights of their fellow students because their principal sure isn't. Shame on you Mr. Davis!

Posted by: holmes county parent Location: holmes county on May 12, 2008 at 10:36 PM
My child attends Holmes County High School. There are alot of so called "gays" that attended HCHS but there as never been the kind of controversey that this act has caused. So what Heather's cousin and friends are gay that doesn't give them any more rights than it does my child who is straight. The school board policy is very strict and straight forward on dress codes and so forth. I would like to see the ones causing all these problems come to Bonifay and stand up to Mrs. Johnson. She wouldn't bat an eye before suspending them. My child has attended different functions at PDL and has been amazed at the difference in how things are tolorated when they are both Holmes County Schools. (dresses at prom and music played etc.)ie same code of conduct book. I hope the judge will think about all the students who will be affected by his decision because it will eventually trickle down to all the kids who are here for education, not to hear their name on the 10 o'clock news. Yea! Mr. Davis!

WJHG.com Features
DTV FAQ’s - Confused about the digital transition? Find everything you need to know right here!
News Only Videos - Tired of Reading the News? You’ll find news video and much more right here.
Money - Top Money and Financial Headlines.
Health Watch - Watch videos and read the latest Health and Medical News.
Pet Pals - See what animals are up for adoption.
Restaurants - Dining in or Out? Find local restaurants here.
Lotto - Find out if you’re a winner!