Current Conditions
Online Poll
Who will win the B-C-S National Championship?

Florida
Oklahoma


Stay Up to Date with WJHG.com














Parent's Complaint May Get Novel Banned In Schools Save Email Print
Posted: 4:41 PM Nov 17, 2008
Last Updated: 9:56 PM Nov 17, 2008
Reporter: Alex Denis
Email Address: Alex.Denis@wjhg.com


A | A | A

The parent of a Choctawhatchee High School student wants the Okaloosa County School Board to ban a novel from the classroom.

"The Kite Runner” takes place in Afghanistan during the fall of the monarchy and focuses on the wrath of the Taliban regime.

The parent says the book's mature content is inappropriate for all high school students, but some school administrators and students disagree.

Critics describe "The Kite Runner” as a powerful and moving portrait of modern Afghanistan.

Students in advanced and honors classes at both Choctaw and Ft. Walton Beach High School read the story as part of the class' curriculum.

But one ft. Walton beach parent has submitted a request for reconsideration of education materials to the Okaloosa County School District.

Diane Kelley, the Director of Curriculum, says “In this particular complaint, that parent sees this work as not worthy of being read by any student. That's the reason why she's taking it forward to both schools in which the book is being used."

The book tells the story of a man who, as a young boy, did nothing when the Taliban raped his friend.

The concerned parent says some of the content in the novel "The Kite Runner” is inappropriate, but some students say the book is relevant especially in today's times.

Sophomore Zack Urenda says, “This is like the real word. This is what goes on in other countries and it really opens your eyes with the war.”

Sophomore Miles Sims says, “So we know what's going on in the world. That's what parents always complain about; you don't know what's going on in the world and everything. These books teach us that."

Ft. Walton Beach's principal says she understands the novel's language is mature, but says teachers are sensitive to the subject.

Charlene Couvillon, FWBHS Principal, says, "Really our students know nothing about, and I didn't as an adult know what life under the Taliban would be about. We just felt like yes it had some pretty mature scenes and mature language but our kids can handle that under the guidance of very, very qualified teachers."

Parents also have the right to request a substitute book for their child.

That's why Principal Charlene Couvillon feels one complaint shouldn't dictate a district-wide ban.

"I think as a parent I have the right to say I don't want my child to read that book but I don't have the right to say that for your child."

The parent's complaint will go before a committee made up of parents, teachers, and administrators.

The group will thoroughly review the sections in question, and then give their recommendation to the school board.

Then school board members will decide if the book should be banned.

“We look at both sides of the issue. We don't deem this to be a light matter at all and constantly consider the value for the student."

News Channel 7 made several attempts to contact the parent for a comment, but wasn't able to reach her.

More Stories
Sansom Case Goes To Grand Jury

Bay County Death Row Inmate For 19 Years, Makes Another Appeal

Milton Historic District Fire

Some Panhandle Farmers Are Trying to Revive Satsuma Orange Industry

Laramore Charges Dropped

Local Bank Robber Is Former S.W. Georgia Mayor

New Revenue Sources

Carlie Brucia Murderer at Supreme Court

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Macy Location: Fountain on Nov 20, 2008 at 11:45 AM
True, Jay. But Annie stated that "Republicans are the ones who try and tell us what is good for us as far as media and music...."

Posted by: Maija Haavisto Location: Finland on Nov 20, 2008 at 10:08 AM
I read "worse" books than that at the age of five (with my parents' implicit consent) and was not harmed in any way. Putting your hands in your ears and pretending nothing bad happens in this world doesn't make it go away. I'm starting to believe sanity is banned in Florida.

Posted by: Jay Location: Lynn Haven on Nov 20, 2008 at 08:50 AM
Wasn't the Fairness Doctrine written for TV and radio broadcasts?

Posted by: Lyle Location: Chipley, FL on Nov 20, 2008 at 08:27 AM
I feel as long as the children are mature enough and have very qualified teachers to deal with the subject that this should not be a problem. True we can try to shelter our children from the world, but what happens when they go out on their own. I never tried to tell my daughter what to read or not read at that age. As far as some of the language, they probably hear worse than that on the street. By the way Annie I am a Republican. Why are people so bad just because they would like to see the Bible back in schools? If you are so opposed to this then why did you end your post with Thank God.

Posted by: Macy Location: Fountain on Nov 19, 2008 at 06:50 PM
And another thing, Annie....funny you ended your statement with 'God'. Did you read about him in the Bible? Just wondering....

Posted by: Macy Location: Fountain on Nov 19, 2008 at 01:55 PM
Um, Annie, have you heard of the Fairness Doctrine? Republicans repealled parts of the Doctrine because it violated free speech rights guaranteed by the First Amendment. Richard Durbin (D-IL), Nancy Pelosi (D), Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) all want to reinstitute the Doctrine. So, Annie, you do some research. As for the book ban, the parent needs to take their student out of the advanced classes and put them in classes so they can read 'Jack and Jill.' Or stay in the advanced classes and learn about other cultures and learn that there are some atrocious places in the world. Their choice.

Posted by: Annie Location: Defuniak Springs on Nov 18, 2008 at 07:14 PM
Geogre, I highly doubt the parents are "liberal scum" since it is republicans who are the ones who try to curb free speech/expression at every turn? If republicans had there way we would be reading the bible in calss, daily. Republicans are the ones who try and tell us what is good for us as far as media and music, fortunately, most people don't want to go back to the Leave it To Beaver era. Do some research George and by the way, liberals are not scum...as a matter of fact, there will be a liberal in the White House in a couple of months. Thank God!!!

Posted by: SheDog Location: Panama City on Nov 18, 2008 at 02:31 PM
Can we all spell censorship??

Posted by: Brian Location: DFS on Nov 18, 2008 at 10:19 AM
This is an excellent novel and a very moving story. Everyone should read this book, including middle and high school students. The parent who is making such a fuss about this book may want to hire a security guard to follow her child around to make sure none of the child's friends use any swear words around them! Give me a break...we are raising sheltered children! This world is cruel and we need to make sure our children know this. Besides, this book is about doing the right thing even if it is years later.

Posted by: George on Nov 18, 2008 at 06:21 AM
I wouldn't be surprised if this parent has some vandalism done to her property. What goes on in those countries is very true. I am 15 years old, an adolescent. The type of parent who wants this to happen is obvoiusly an overly protective liberal piece of scum. I can see the stupidity that reeks of this parent. We have a right to read what we desire. To me, the book sounds very moving. It shouldn't get banned.

Posted by: Miggity on Nov 17, 2008 at 07:03 PM
These students are in advanced and honors classes, and are from 15 - 18 yrs old, and yet we have a parent worried about the content? Just how much do they want to shelter their children? If it's a good piece of literature, and these children are almost adults, some of them already legal adults, then what's the complaint? How dare we open our childrens eyes to the world stage. This parent is complaining about the content of a book. Gee, I wonder how the parents in war ravaged countries like Iraq feel. They'd probably laugh in this parents face because their "poor" child had to read a reality.

Be a Citizen Journalist