New Mammogram Guidelines Spark Debate

By: Josh Gauntt Email
By: Josh Gauntt Email

Joni Erlewein is 44 years old. She routinely gets mammograms, believing early detection is key to avoiding breast cancer.

But a new the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, which is made up of 16 health care experts, now says women under the age of 50 should not get routine mammograms.

"I think it's a little bit scary because women should really have the right to have a mammogram," Erlewein said.

The group is recommending women ages 40 to 49 should talk to their doctors to find out the benefits and risks of the exam. They also recommend women between the ages of 50 through 75 should get mammograms not annually but every two years. Here's why.

"That is, the likelihood of having a false positive test with all the attendant anxiety, the additional imaging tests, perhaps even leading to biopsy that may have been unnecessary," Dr. Diana Petitti, of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force said.

Local health experts strongly disagree. Kim Lydick has been a registered nurse for years. She's also a volunteer for the American Cancer Society, which is sticking by what it's been preaching for years.

"And they still say at 40 years old, every woman should still get an annual mammogram, screening mammogram and continue throughout life," Lydick said.

Critics say these new recommendations are the beginning of President Obama's new health care plan, which could force some insurance companies to drop coverage of mammograms.

"They are trying to do the new health care system. Government run, cut costs," Lydick said.

"They make recommendations. They don't make policy. What I wanted to clarify is that we don't intend to change any coverage," Kathleen Sebelius, Health and Human Services Secretary said.

The task force says the guidelines are only recommendations and that you should still talk to your doctor.

The task force also says there's no need to teach women to do self-breast exams. That may shock you, but for the past five years, the government and the American Cancer Society said there's not enough evidence to recommend that women do the monthly exams.

You must be logged in to post comments.

Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by annoymous Location: pcb on Nov 20, 2009 at 07:04 PM
    So there talking about people not needing mamograms until 50 years old but do they even consider the though about people that have families to where every female has ended up with breast cancer before the age of 30??? wake up and think people!!! Every woman in my family has ended up with breast cancer before the age of 30 and if i dont get it then I will be the lucky one they need to look at this from every view possible before they jump into this it just disgusts me!!!!
  • by WC Location: Panama City on Nov 20, 2009 at 05:58 PM
    Who appointed these people? Where did they come from. What are their qualifications and education? Wake up America "BIG BROTHER" is here. Your right to proper medical care is being controlled by the government and this is just the beginning.
8195 Front Beach Road Panama City Beach, FL 32407 Station: 850-234-7777 News: 850-230-5221 Fax: 850-233-6647
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 70570267 -
Gray Television, Inc.