Evolution vs. Creationism
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 9:27 PM Jan 11, 2008
Evolution vs. Creationism
Evolution could be coming to your children’s science classrooms. A panel of education experts just wrapped up three days of meetings at the state Department of Education to hammer out new standards. The state Board of Education will have the final say next month.
Posted: 3:46 PM Jan 11, 2008
Reporter: Chris Casquejo
Font Size:

Evolution could be coming to your children’s science classrooms. A panel of education experts just wrapped up three days of meetings at the state Department of Education to hammer out new standards. The state Board of Education will have the final say next month.

The way science is taught in Florida public school classrooms could soon change. Right now, the state science curriculum uses the words “biological changes over time” instead of “evolution".

Biology teacher Nicholas Daigle believes the current standards shortchange students.

“It’s very hard to teach good biological science without mentioning evolution. It’s one of the basic underpinnings of modern biological science.

A panel of more than 50 educators met over the past three days to hammer out the finishing touches on the new science standards.

Since work began on the new standards last May, the state Department of Education has heard from more than 10,000 people. Many believe that evolution should be taught as just one theory. They want the state board to include alternatives, such as intelligent design.

Mary Jane Tappen from the Department of Education says the board will take it all into consideration.

“There are multiple view to include evolution, the theory of evolution, to not include it, to include it and other theories. So they’ll get all those facts."

Governor Charlie Crist is taking a wait and see attitude.

“I think the way it’s been handled historically in Florida is probably appropriate. It’s been introduced and discussed in terms of being a theory. I don’t know if there’s a need for a change in that. But I’ll leave the decision to the board.”

The State Board of Education will vote on the new standards on February 19th. Public comment on the Florida Department of Education’s website ended on December 14th.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Archangel Location: Seattke on Jan 17, 2010 at 03:38 PM

ID requires facts, such as life was created by an Intelligent being or beings. It could not have evolved in incremental steps as Darwin proposed with his 19th century limited understanding of biology. We understand now that a cell is not just a sack of protoplasm, but a collection of "biological machines" acting in perfect harmony. The bacterial flagellum is irreducibly complex, comprised of 60 components which had to exist as a built product for the flagellum to work. Slow change over time would not account for these 59 vestigial components which would have served no purpose except to hinder the bacteria which supported them. How are those for facts?
Posted by: Sunny Location: Florida on Feb 24, 2008 at 05:00 PM

To the previous comment: ID is a belief and therefore requires no facts. It is an opinion offered as an alternative to a faulty theory. Evolution, while holding many components that have a strong possibility, can not and has not been proven. Fossil records have been shown, by the same scientific community, to be, in many cases, completely inaccurate- such as in the radioisotope dating from Mt. Ngauruhoe, which proposed that volcanic flow known to be around 50 years of age, was over a million years old. As for your issues with the "cherry-picking" of biblical evidence, a true look into Christian beliefs or a study of the New Testament would inform you that, through the life and death of Jesus Christ, Christians believe that the teachings of the Old Testament were made false and unnecessary. What is cherry-picking, however, is picking out a single verse without reading the context or follow-up to explain its meaning. Everyone deserves respect for their views whether you agree with them or not. Maybe you should look into possible errors in your own theories before you criticize those of others.
Posted by: Stop the Insanity Location: PA on Jan 18, 2008 at 01:08 PM

To those arguing for ID: At it's core, science is really about intellectual honesty. Scientists will change their views when the evidence demands it. So, it is very dishonest of you to say: "There is no proof of evolution" when scientists consider it fact, overwhelmingly supported by the fossil record and genetic research. "Something can't come from nothing, so God created the universe", and when shown that the same logic means that God can't come from nothing either, say "God is different" "ID is a valid scientific theory" even after you've been told that a scientific theory explains accepted facts about empirical observations and does not mean "opinion". "Teach the controversy" when there is none. "The bible is the literal word of god", then cherry-pick the "good stuff" and ignore technical/historical errors and horrific biblical teachings such as "Kill those who don't believe in Me" or "You may sell your daughter into slavery". You deserve no respect for these views.
Headlines - msnbc.com
  • For mentally ill inmates, care behind bars often out of reach
    A man who was declared suicidal by a New Mexico jail and alleges he was then left to rot in solitary confinement for nearly two years is just one of many former inmates who say they were denied essential mental health services while incarcerated at that detention center, which like others across the country has struggled with how to treat the mentally ill.
  • American aid worker in Libya: US bars my return

    U.S. citizen Jamal Tarhuni went to his native Libya to conduct aid work and now finds himself prevented from flying home by American officials for mysterious reasons.U.S. citizen Jamal Tarhuni went to his native Libya to conduct aid work and now finds himself prevented from flying home by American officials for mysterious reasons.


  • Report: Climate of 'mistrust' in air marshal program
    The Federal Air Marshal program is rife with acrimony between supervisors and air marshals, creating a climate of "tension, mistrust, and dislike," according to a report due to be released next week.
  • Police: Missing barista abducted from stand

    An 18-year-old barista who disappeared from the coffee stand where she worked was abducted, Anchorage police say.An 18-year-old barista who disappeared from the coffee stand where she worked was abducted, Anchorage police say.


  • Court martial ordered in WikiLeaks case

    Bradley Manning, the Army private accused in the WikiLeaks scandal, was ordered Friday to face a general court martial on charges he released thousands of documents of classified information. Bradley Manning, the Army private accused in the WikiLeaks scandal, was ordered Friday to face a general court martial on charges he released thousands of documents of classified information.


  • American brigadier general dies in Afghanistan

    A 49-year-old brigadier general died of apparently natural causes in Afghanistan, the Army said Friday, the highest-ranking soldier to die during the war. A 49-year-old brigadier general died of apparently natural causes in Afghanistan, the Army said Friday, the highest-ranking soldier to die during the war.


  • Charges dropped against soldier in Afghan deaths
    The Army on Friday dropped all charges against the fifth soldier accused of murdering Afghan civilians for sport during a 2010 deployment, in one of the most gruesome cases to emerge from the Afghan war.
  • Cold case: 1940s starlet's death befuddles cops
    It was one of those cases that seemed straight out of pulp fiction, a noir mystery written by one of those hard-boiled scribes who liked to surround damsels in distress with mobsters and movie stars.  Yet it was real life.
  • 30 marijuana bales found floating off Calif. beach
    About $500,000 worth of marijuana was found floating off the coast of Marina del Rey, Calif., Wednesday afternoon, police said.
  • Nuclear plant worker fell into reactor pool

    A worker was leaning over to retrieve a flashlight when he lost his balance and fell into a reactor pool at the San Onofre nuclear power plant last week, plant officials say.A worker was leaning over to retrieve a flashlight when he lost his balance and fell into a reactor pool at the San Onofre nuclear power plant last week, plant officials say.


  • Recovery is gathering speed, jobs data show

    The U.S. economy is like a flywheel: it takes a lot to get it going. Once it starts moving, it can pick up speed pretty quickly.The U.S. economy is like a flywheel — it takes a lot to get it going. But once it starts moving, it can pick up speed pretty quickly. Friday’s January jobs report shows it’s accelerating.


  • Nasdaq hits 11-year high as stocks jump
    A surge in hiring last month boosted stock prices Friday, with the technology sector hitting an 11-year high as the data boosted hopes the world's largest economy has turned a corner.
  • Jobless rate lowest in almost three years
    The U.S. economy creates jobs at the fastest pace in 9 months and the jobless rate drops to an almost 3-year low, raising hopes that the labor market is picking up steam.
  • Do you think economy has turned the corner?
    The government reported Friday that the U.S. economy created jobs at the fastest pace in nine months in January. Do you think the recovery is accelerating?
  • Micron CEO Appleton dies in plane crash
    By msnbc.com staff and wire Steve Appleton, Chairman and CEO of Micron Technology, has passed away in a small plane accident in Boise, Idaho, the company said Friday.
  • N.Y. foreclosure lawsuit could slow home seizures
    Bankers struggling to deal with faulty foreclosure paperwork just got hit with another major headache. New York State Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, recently tapped by President Obama to head a new task force to investigate mortgage fraud, sued three major U.S.
  • Where the (good) jobs are coming from

      We already know that one key way to make more money and stay employed is to get more education.  We already know that one key way to make more money and stay employed is to get more education.


  • Companies paid even lower tax rate than Romney
    According to new data from the Congressional Budget Office, U.S.-based companies paid only 12.1 percent in taxes on profits earned domestically. This is the lowest rate in four decades.
  • Woman accused of selling fake Facebook stock
    A Wisconsin woman has been charged with theft over accusations she tried to profit from Facebook's much-anticipated plans to go public by selling fake stock in the social media giant.
  • Slideshow: What you can get for ... $400,000

    Each week, TODAY real estate expert Barbara Corcoran looks around the U.S. to see what home buyers can get for their money. Each week, TODAY real estate expert Barbara Corcoran looks around the U.S. to see what home buyers can get for their money.


  • Lawsuit: Gulf oil spill still leaking after 7 years

    Environmental groups on Thursday sued an oil company over the pace of its cleanup of a Gulf of Mexico spill that continues seven years after it was triggered by Hurricane Ivan in 2004.Environmental groups on Thursday sued an oil company over the pace of its cleanup of a Gulf of Mexico spill that continues seven years after it was triggered by Hurricane Ivan in 2004.




    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Forecasters in stormy debate over climate
    Whether mankind is behind warming temperatures is an issue that's divided the American Meteorological Society, whose members are Americans' prime source of news about weather.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Glacier theft suspects on thin ice with Chilean police

    Thieves have stolen 11,000 pounds of ancient ice from a Chilean glacier to make designer cubes for cocktails in bars in the nation's capital, Santiago, authorities have told local media.Thieves have stolen 11,000 pounds of ancient ice from a Chilean glacier to make designer cubes for cocktails in bars in the nation's capital, Santiago, authorities have told local media.




    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • US: Mid-Atlantic wind farms take step forward
    Offshore wind farms from New Jersey to Virginia took a big step closer to reality with the completion of a review that showed the renewable energy source would leave no major environmental damage, officials said Thursday.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • US estimates tritium release at Illinois reactor
    The trace amount of radioactive tritium released in steam to cool a reactor during a shutdown at an Illinois nuclear plant was not enough to present a danger to the public, according to the first estimates by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Sponsored By:
  • Air shipment of 60 lab monkeys blocked, PETA says

    A daylong bombardment of emails, social media posts and phone calls led Air France to cancel a planned shipment Wednesday of monkeys to a testing lab in the U.S.A daylong bombardment of emails, social media posts and phone calls led Air France to cancel a planned shipment Wednesday of monkeys to a testing lab in the U.S.




    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Filmmaker arrested at House hearing on shale gas
    The director of a U.S. documentary that portrays shale gas production as dangerous was arrested and escorted out of a Republican-dominated Congressional hearing on Wednesday, touching off a dispute over public access to the event.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Feds declare Atlantic sturgeon endangered species
    The Atlantic sturgeon, a prehistoric fish whose once bountiful populations were depleted by anglers seeking its coveted caviar, has been declared an endangered species by federal officials, a decision that could lead to moves to protect its habitats along the East Coast.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine
  • Small radiation amount 'could have' escaped plant
    An "extremely small" amount of radiation could have escaped from a Southern California nuclear power plant after a water leak prompted operators to shut down the reactor, a utility spokesman said Wednesday.

    Email this Article Add to Newsvine