Evolution Debate
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 10:14 PM Feb 7, 2008
Evolution Debate
The Bay District School Board is about to enter the fight over whether evolution should be taught as fact or theory.
Posted: 4:00 PM Feb 7, 2008

Evolution
Font Size:

The Bay District School Board is about to enter the fight over whether evolution should be taught as fact or theory.

At next Wednesday's board meeting, the panel will decide whether to approve a resolution opposing the proposed teaching of evolution as a scientific fact. That's six days before the state Board of Education decides whether to adopt new sunshine state standards for science.

Those standards present evolution as "the fundamental concept underlying all of biology, and is supported in multiple forms of scientific evidence".

The proposed local resolution calls for the teaching of the scientific strengths and weaknesses of the evolution "theory", rather than teaching it as dogmatic fact.

The resolution is similar to those adopted by several area school boards. and Marianna State Representative Marti Coley is urging the legislature to add the word "theory" in a new evolution bill.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Joel Location: Iowa on Feb 20, 2008 at 12:49 PM

It is nice to see that the people of Florida are addressing the critical issues of our times. I wish the state of Iowa would address this rather than such silly issues like health care, maintaining our infrastructer and funding our public schools.
Posted by: Sonia Location: Orlando on Feb 11, 2008 at 11:08 AM

The word "theory" in scientific usage means a group of ideas that are supported by quite a lot of experimental evidence. In contrast, a "theory" in normal English can be just a random idea that you come up with one day, with no evidence to support you. The theory of evolution is the first kind of theory- it is supported by evidence ranging from fossils to genes to the ability of some bacteria to develop resistance to certain types of antibiotics. In contrast, there's no evidence supporting Intelligent Design- it's basically just an idea that a group of people came up with one day. Let's keep evolution in the science classroom where it belongs with other scientific theories, like the theory of gravity or the theory that the earth revolves around the sun. If people are uncomfortable with the idea that all life, including humans, is related, that should be discussed in a philosophy or religion class.
Posted by: Adam Location: Arkansas on Feb 11, 2008 at 03:04 AM

Evolution is a fact in that it is an observable phenomenon (change through time has happened). The theory (no, not the everyday "hunch" kind of theory) of evolution by natural selection is the best fit model to explain how changes in organisms has come about over time. There is NO evidence that goes against evolution as an explanation yet it would take very little, say, a fossil out of place, to refute the whole of evolutionary theory. In fact all of the evidence fits nicely with this model. This is contrasted with ID which is not a scientific concept because it is not falsifiable. In other words, there is no evidence, if found, that could be put forth to refute it. The claim that organisms are simply too complex to have arisen through natural processes is a negative claim about evolution. "God did it!" is NOT a satisfactory answer because it explains nothing. Science as a method is opposed to dogmatism precisely because it seeks explanations based on empirical evidence.
Headlines - msnbc.com
  • Docs diagnose Harry Potter's headaches

    After years of studying, experts think they've figured out what was ailing Harry Potter all those years -- a  nummular headache.After years of studying, experts think they've figured out what was ailing Harry Potter all those years -- a  nummular headache.


  • Is it Alzheimer's, or mild cognitive impairment?
    Almost everyone currently diagnosed with a mild form of Alzheimer's disease would be downgraded to not having the condition, if new proposed criteria for the diagnosis of cognitive problems were applied, a new study shows.
  • Study: Child abuse bigger threat than SIDS
    In the first national estimate of serious injuries due to child abuse, Yale University researchers say 4,600 U.S. children were hospitalized with broken bones, traumatic brain injury and other serious damage caused by abuse. Babies younger than one were the most common victims.
  • Facebook takes a toll on your mental health
    By Stephanie PappasLiveScience Facebook's initial public offering of stock is likely to make a lot of developers and designers of the site very wealthy.
  • Sex-ed less effective in red states, study says
    By Christopher WanjekLiveScience Sex education is failing to reduce adolescent birthrates in conservative states, according to a new study. Perhaps paradoxically, states with a majority conservative population and higher degree of religiosity tend to have higher teen birthrates.
  • Spanking linked to more aggression in kids
    A review of 20 years of research finds that physically disciplining a child has long-term, harmful effects on their development.
  • CDC: 1 in 5 kids exposed to secondhand smoke in cars
    Texting while driving, speeding and back-seat hanky-panky aren't all that parents need to worry about when their kids are in cars: Add secondhand smoke to the list.
  • 11 instant mood-boosting foods

    Dark chocolate, blue potatoes and lemon macaroons! Find out what other surprising foods can help feed your brain and improve mood. Dark chocolate, blue potatoes and lemon macaroons! Find out what other surprising foods can help feed your brain and improve mood.


  • Study: Green tea could be secret to healthy old age
    Elderly adults who regularly drink green tea may stay more agile and independent than their peers over time, according to a Japanese study that covered thousands of people.
  • Supporters grapple with fallout over Komen cuts

    Fierce controversy over a policy that cut -- then apparently restored -- funding for Planned Parenthood by the Susan G.Fierce controversy over a policy that cut -- then apparently restored -- funding for Planned Parenthood by the Susan G.


  • US shutters embassy in Syria, withdraws staff
    The US has closed its embassy in Damascus and withdrawn all American diplomats from Syria as President Assad's deadly crackdown on rebels continues.
  • 'Deceptive practices': US levies new sanctions on Iran
    WASHINGTON -- President Barack Obama ordered new U.S. sanctions on the government of Iran, including the Central Bank, on Monday.
  • European politician taps into fear, sex appeal

    A Flemish nationalist politician in Belgium has launched a new campaign that taps into anxiety about the country’s immigrant Muslim population, while capitalizing on the svelte figure of his 19-year-old daughter.A Flemish nationalist politician in Belgium has launched a new campaign that taps into anxiety about the country’s immigrant Muslim population, while capitalizing on the svelte figure of his 19-year-old daughter.


  • 6.8 quake in Philippines kills 13, buries homes

    A strong earthquake in the Philippines killed at least 13 people Monday as it destroyed buildings and triggered landslides that buried dozens of houses, trapping residents.A strong earthquake in the Philippines killed at least 13 people Monday as it destroyed buildings and triggered landslides that buried dozens of houses, trapping residents.


  • Israel: Palestinian deal abandons 'way of peace'
    The main Palestinian political rivals took a major step Monday toward healing their bitter rift, agreeing that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas would head an interim unity government to prepare for general elections in the West Bank and Gaza.
  • European freeze disrupts schools, transit

    People walk on a frozen path alongside Lake Geneva in Coppet, Switzerland, on Monday.Overwhelmed by deep snow and harsh temperatures, some countries in Europe closed down schools and struggled to run public transport Monday, as post-snow rains caused a dam to collapse in Bulgaria, flooding a village and killing at least four.


  • Greece plays game of chicken over bailout

    A Greek and an EU flag fly atop the Greek ministry of finance as a storm, literally and financially, looms over Athens.Greece let yet another deadline slip on Monday for responding to painful terms for a new EU/IMF bailout as patience in Brussels wore thin over drawn-out negotiations among its feuding political leaders.


  • Aww, man! Bart Simpson joins Barbie in Iran ban
    TEHRAN -- The Simpsons are corroding the morals of Iranian youth, an official said on Monday, as dolls based on Bart, Homer and the rest of the American cartoon family joined the shapely Barbie among Western toys targeted by a new crackdown in Tehran.
  • Radical preacher to be released, UK judge rules
    A British court ruled Monday that an extremist cleric described as one of Europe's leading al-Qaida operatives should be released on bail.
  • Egypt speeds up work for presidential vote

    An Egyptian man stands in front of riot police blocking the road during clashes with protestors near the Interior Ministry in Cairo, Egypt, on Saturday.Egypt's military leader told electoral officials Monday to speed preparations for presidential elections after a new eruption of street protests demanding that the ruling generals move more quickly to hand power to an elected government.