Woman Fired for Allegedly Not Saying Happy Holidays
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 10:30 AM Dec 24, 2008
Woman Fired for Allegedly Not Saying Happy Holidays
Panama City Woman Claims she was fired from her job for allegedly not saying Happy Holidays
Posted: 11:13 PM Dec 23, 2008
Reporter: Josh Gauntt
Email Address: joshua.gauntt@wjhg.com

Woman Fired - 10 PM
Woman Fired for Holiday Greeting 6 PM
width:240 and height: 180 and picwidth: 240 and pciheight: 180
Font Size:

Tonia Thomas used to be an employee at Counts Oakes Resort Properties in Lynn Haven. But that job came to an end two weeks ago in a dispute with her boss Andy Phillips over a telephone greeting for the holidays.

"Andy told me that if I don't say the Happy Holidays script as written, he would fire me," Thomas said.

Thomas says for religious reasons she couldn't say Happy Holiday when answering the company's telephone. She wanted to say Merry Christmas.

Andy Phillips, the company's President said what is being reported in the media is false and said he fired Thomas for different reasons.

"We have a situation with a disgruntled employee who was terminated for insubordination and gross misconduct. She was not terminated and I want to make that very clear, she was not terminated for saying Merry Christmas," Phillips said.

Phillips says the greeting his employees are supposed to say changed after Thanksgiving and he felt the need not to single out any other holiday this time of the year.

"But there's also Hanukkah and we want to make sure we put a script in place that was not offensive to someone who did not celebrate Christmas," Phillips said.

Thomas says her personnel file is spotless and still can't believe she was fired.

Since then, she has contacted Liberty Counsel, a legal representation firm based in Orlando. She says she is filing suit against her former employer for lost wages.

"They have sent notice to the company to Counts that they were taking the case and we basically sent a demand letter over," Thomas said.

Thomas did find another job and says she is thankful.

"Although I felt like I was standing alone when I was fighting this, I knew that God was beside me and that he led me to this job," Thomas said.

Phillips did not reveal any specifics about the firing of Thomas, but he did say it will come out when the lawsuit proceeds.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Don Location: Marietta, GA on Dec 30, 2008 at 10:58 AM

Her employer decides what she says when she's on the clock. If she had a case, a "secular" law firm would've taken it. Since she doesn't, she's got a right wing firm that will milk it for publicity while losing.
Posted by: Lilly Location: Lynn Haven on Dec 30, 2008 at 10:32 AM

Jesus read all of these comments. Better check yourselves! Happy Birthday Jesus and please forgive the unbelievers.
Posted by: cindy Location: Panama CIty on Dec 30, 2008 at 02:12 AM

Thank you Tonia for standing up for what you believe.
Headlines - msnbc.com
  • Paternity questions plague 1 in 10, firm says

    The company that made its name peddling drugstore paternity tests to uncertain parents now says that more than 1 in 10 adults in the U.S. has had reason to ask the question: Who’s your Daddy? Gary Garner finally confirmed he's the real father of Skyler, 14. The company that made its name peddling drugstore paternity tests to uncertain parents now says that more than 1 in 10 adults in the U.S. has had reason to ask the question: Who’s your Daddy? Gary Garner finally confirmed he's the real father of Skyler, 14.


  • CDC: 9 in 10 Americans eat too much salt
    Despite public health messages telling Americans to lower the amount of salt in their diets, 90 percent of people in the U.S. older than age 2 consume more than the recommended amount of sodium each day, a new report says.
  • Komen's Karen Handel quits after funding dispute
    Karen Handel, an executive with the Susan G. Komen for the Cure breast-cancer charity has resigned after a dispute over funding for Planned Parenthood.
  • Have we met? Face blindness prevents recognition
    Some people are better at recognizing a face. Now a study of individuals who have prosopagnosia, a disorder rendering them unable to distinguish another's mug, suggests a possible cause: a breakdown in a brain pathway used to process faces.
  • Distraction reduces pain, study finds
    By Joseph BrownsteinMyHealthNewsDailyWhen you distract yourself from pain, you actually hurt less, a new study suggests.
  • Is it Alzheimer's, or mild cognitive impairment?
    Almost everyone currently diagnosed with a mild form of Alzheimer's disease would be downgraded to not having the condition, if new proposed criteria for the diagnosis of cognitive problems were applied, a new study shows.
  • College vending machine offers 'morning-after' pill
    Students at a Pennsylvania university can obtain the "morning-after" pill from an unusual source — a vending machine at the campus health center.
  • Obama increases Alzheimer's research funding
    The Obama administration announced Tuesday it is increasing spending on Alzheimer's research — planning to surpass half a billion dollars next year — as part of a quest to find effective treatments for the brain-destroying disease by 2025.
  • Doctors diagnose Harry Potter's headaches

    After years of studying, experts think they've figured out what was ailing Harry Potter all those years -- a  nummular headache.After years of studying, experts think they've figured out what was ailing Harry Potter all those years -- a  nummular headache.


  • Study: Child abuse bigger threat than SIDS
    In the first national estimate of serious injuries due to child abuse, Yale University researchers say 4,600 U.S. children were hospitalized with broken bones, traumatic brain injury and other serious damage caused by abuse. Babies younger than one were the most common victims.
  • Second wind for Santorum with victories in Minn., Mo., Co.
    Rick Santorum scored victories in Minnesota and Missouri nominating contests Tuesday night, winning him no actual delegates, but allowing him to stymie Mitt Romney's bid to keep alive a streak of victories in the Republican presidential primary.
  • Make or break time for Santorum
    First Read: Contests in Colorado, Minnesota and Missouri offer the former Pennsylvania senator an opportunity break through once more.
  • Some Dems seeking reversal on contraception decision
    Some congressional Democrats were working behind the scenes Tuesday to persuade Obama to reverse course; some warned of a potential threat to the president’s re-election chances in states with large Catholic populations.
  • First Read: A 'Super' reversal
    Anyone who is surprised by the Obama campaign's announcement last night that it's encouraging Democratic donors to give money to the pro-Obama Super PAC wasn't paying attention in 2008.
  • Group wants criminal investigation of Super PACs
    First Read: A top campaign watchdog group is calling for a Justice Department criminal investigation into Super PACs supporting President Obama and GOP front runner Mitt Romney.
  • Messy caucuses in Nevada, Iowa raise questions
    After back-to-back fiascos in Nevada and Iowa, the term "caucus" may be on its way to becoming a bad word in the GOP lexicon.
  • Texas primary date in doubt after deal talks stall
    Texas is all but certain to have an even later say in choosing the Republican presidential nominee after what at first looked like a breakthrough deal over redistricting maps ended with wide rejection of the proposal.
  • Earmarks fund projects near lawmakers' properties
    Members of Congress have pushed more than $300 million in earmarks and other provisions to projects near their own properties, the Washington Post reported on Tuesday.
  • Romney shifts focus to Santorum ahead caucuses
    First Read: Mitt Romney's campaign has trained its sights on Rick Santorum over the past 48 hours, demonstrating that Santorum may pose the freshest threat to their frontrunner status.
  • Senate approves long-stalled aviation bill
    The Senate voted Monday afternoon to approve a House-passed bill aimed at improving the nation’s aviation infrastructure and modernizing air traffic control systems.